Thoughts about Who gave Harry a bulging bag of Dungbombs for Christmas?
Please read our Terms of Service if this is your first time using the Pensieve.
qwertyuiop wrote:
I think you should do all gifts. The two-way mirror has to make the list even though it wasn’t for Christmas.
— August 17, 2006 @ 12:31 pm
Lisa wrote:
Erm, can I reply to myself? I added a column to the chart so now there is room for both Christmas and birthday gifts. I’m worried the font is too small…
— August 18, 2006 @ 1:08 am
Lisa wrote:
Good catch, Elsbeth, and thanks! Bel sent me a list last night that I haven’t finished adding to the chart yet. Now I’m thinking of doing a list of all the books we can confirm that Harry has read =). I came across quite a few as I was researching the gifts.
— August 18, 2006 @ 10:53 am
Reader2 wrote:
Speaking of books, in CoS Harry got a set of books from Lockhart and then gave them to Ginny.
The fact that Ginny is nowhere on the chart is strange as it is.
— August 18, 2006 @ 12:06 pm
Pumpkin Pasty wrote:
Great list. I’ve tried doing this in the past and emailing it to the Lexicon, but yours is more comprehensive and satisfying to peruse. Many thanks.
— August 19, 2006 @ 3:02 am
Pteris Vittata wrote:
Let’s not forget Ginny’s gift of a Singing Valentine, what gift is greater than Love? Or have I launched into the world of microscopic nitpicking? heh…
Oh, and didn’t someone give Harry his own Wizard Chess set?
— August 25, 2006 @ 9:13 pm
Lisa wrote:
Senor Poncho, Great memory, but Seamus lent Harry his chess set so it wasn’t a gift.
I will think about your Dobby suggestion; there are so many intangible things that Harry has given that I may need to keep the list restricted to physical objects.
— August 25, 2006 @ 11:54 pm
Lisa wrote:
My apologies to Senor Poncho! Harry received a Wizard chess set in his Christmas dinner crackers his first year at Hogwarts. I have added it to the chart.
Didn’t Harry and Ron give Crabbe and Goyle the cakes with the sleeping potion?
— August 27, 2006 @ 2:49 am
moony wrote:
Love, advise, friendship, … information (Dobby e.g. about room of requirement or gillyweet), … are as important as presents or chocolate. But the list would be too long if you include this. Perhaps you can include “imaterial items” and give three examples of this, followed by … ?
— August 27, 2006 @ 7:07 am
moony wrote:
Concerning the list, you also can link to “Harry’s things”, an essay by morag Traynor.
— August 27, 2006 @ 7:36 am
Siri wrote:
The picture above the chart, of Lupin keeping Harry from going after Sirius, seems to have disappeared lately – at least I’m only getting the frame.
— August 27, 2006 @ 4:33 pm
Chumlor the Mighty wrote:
In my fan fiction novelette “Harry Potter and the Amphibious Grindylow,” I mention that Hermione gives Harry a Silver Sickle and Ron gives him an Underwater Compass that always points to Atlantis. Harry does lose the Sickle, but I’m hoping the compass will appear in my next fan fiction story.
Okay you don’t like the immaterial things, but how about, to Lucius Malfoy (sorry if I got the spelling wrong): One sock with destroyed dairy of Tom Riddle, which Lucius inadvertently gave to Dobby freeing him. If you put that you might as well add the Dumbledore let gave (let him have it) to him.
qwertyuiop wrote:
I think you should do all gifts. The two-way mirror has to make the list even though it wasn’t for Christmas.
— August 17, 2006 @ 12:31 pm
Lisa wrote:
Erm, can I reply to myself? I added a column to the chart so now there is room for both Christmas and birthday gifts. I’m worried the font is too small…
— August 18, 2006 @ 1:08 am
Lisa wrote:
Good catch, Elsbeth, and thanks! Bel sent me a list last night that I haven’t finished adding to the chart yet. Now I’m thinking of doing a list of all the books we can confirm that Harry has read =). I came across quite a few as I was researching the gifts.
— August 18, 2006 @ 10:53 am
Reader2 wrote:
Speaking of books, in CoS Harry got a set of books from Lockhart and then gave them to Ginny.
The fact that Ginny is nowhere on the chart is strange as it is.
— August 18, 2006 @ 12:06 pm
Pumpkin Pasty wrote:
Great list. I’ve tried doing this in the past and emailing it to the Lexicon, but yours is more comprehensive and satisfying to peruse. Many thanks.
— August 19, 2006 @ 3:02 am
Pteris Vittata wrote:
Let’s not forget Ginny’s gift of a Singing Valentine, what gift is greater than Love? Or have I launched into the world of microscopic nitpicking? heh…
— August 19, 2006 @ 8:35 pm
Senor Poncho wrote:
Oh, and didn’t someone give Harry his own Wizard Chess set?
— August 25, 2006 @ 9:13 pm
Lisa wrote:
Senor Poncho, Great memory, but Seamus lent Harry his chess set so it wasn’t a gift.
I will think about your Dobby suggestion; there are so many intangible things that Harry has given that I may need to keep the list restricted to physical objects.
— August 25, 2006 @ 11:54 pm
Lisa wrote:
My apologies to Senor Poncho! Harry received a Wizard chess set in his Christmas dinner crackers his first year at Hogwarts. I have added it to the chart.
— August 26, 2006 @ 12:50 pm
Danny wrote:
Didn’t Harry and Ron give Crabbe and Goyle the cakes with the sleeping potion?
— August 27, 2006 @ 2:49 am
moony wrote:
Love, advise, friendship, … information (Dobby e.g. about room of requirement or gillyweet), … are as important as presents or chocolate. But the list would be too long if you include this. Perhaps you can include “imaterial items” and give three examples of this, followed by … ?
— August 27, 2006 @ 7:07 am
moony wrote:
Concerning the list, you also can link to “Harry’s things”, an essay by morag Traynor.
— August 27, 2006 @ 7:36 am
Siri wrote:
The picture above the chart, of Lupin keeping Harry from going after Sirius, seems to have disappeared lately – at least I’m only getting the frame.
— August 27, 2006 @ 4:33 pm
Chumlor the Mighty wrote:
In my fan fiction novelette “Harry Potter and the Amphibious Grindylow,” I mention that Hermione gives Harry a Silver Sickle and Ron gives him an Underwater Compass that always points to Atlantis. Harry does lose the Sickle, but I’m hoping the compass will appear in my next fan fiction story.
— August 27, 2006 @ 7:05 pm
Senor Poncho wrote:
Okay you don’t like the immaterial things, but how about, to Lucius Malfoy (sorry if I got the spelling wrong): One sock with destroyed dairy of Tom Riddle, which Lucius inadvertently gave to Dobby freeing him. If you put that you might as well add the Dumbledore let gave (let him have it) to him.
— August 31, 2006 @ 2:27 am